Medicare Denied Claim: Car Accident or Work Injury
Did Medicare deny your claim because a car accident or work injury was involved?
"Medicare denied my claim because of a car accident"
"Workers' compensation should have paid first"
"Another insurer should pay before Medicare"
"Medicare says this injury is covered by auto or workers' comp insurance"
Let's sort out which insurer is responsible and how to get your bills covered.
What This Means
Medicare denied your claim because it believes another insurer should pay first. Under a federal law called the Medicare Secondary Payer (MSP) Act, Medicare generally does not pay for care that another insurer has paid for, or can be expected to pay for promptly.
This usually happens when your care is related to:
- A car accident — your auto insurance (or the other driver’s insurance) is expected to pay first
- A work injury — workers’ compensation is expected to pay first
- Another person’s negligence — liability insurance may be responsible
In these situations Medicare is the secondary payer. It pays after the other insurer, or pays conditionally when that insurer does not pay promptly and is repaid later.
Why This Happens
- You were in a car accident. No-fault auto insurance or the at-fault driver’s liability insurance is required to pay before Medicare. This applies even if the accident happened years ago, as long as treatment is still related to the accident.
- You were injured on the job. Workers’ compensation covers job-related injuries and illnesses. Medicare will not pay for care that workers’ comp should cover.
- Medicare’s records show other insurance is involved. Medicare’s Benefits Coordination & Recovery Center (BCRC) tracks information about other insurance. If they know about your accident or injury, claims may be denied automatically.
- Your provider did not bill the correct insurer first. The claim may have been sent to Medicare before the primary insurer had a chance to process it.
Should You Appeal?
Whether to appeal depends on your specific situation:
- If the injury really is covered by auto insurance or workers’ comp, an appeal of the Medicare denial will not succeed. The other insurer needs to pay first.
- If workers’ comp or auto insurance denied your claim, you may be able to get Medicare to pay by providing proof of that denial.
- If your treatment is not related to the accident or work injury, ask your provider to check that the claim’s diagnosis codes show the unrelated condition and to resubmit it. If Medicare’s record of your accident or injury case is wrong, call the BCRC to correct it. You can also appeal, with a note from your doctor explaining why the care is unrelated.
The key question is whether another insurer is truly responsible for the care in question.
What To Do Next
- Figure out which insurer should pay first. If your care is related to a car accident, contact your auto insurer. If it is related to a work injury, contact your employer’s workers’ compensation carrier.
- File a claim with the responsible insurer. Your provider’s billing office may need to submit the claim to the correct insurer first before Medicare will consider it.
- If the other insurer denied your claim, gather the denial letter and send it to your provider’s billing office. They can resubmit to Medicare with proof that the other insurer will not pay.
- Report the case to the BCRC. CMS says you must notify the Benefits Coordination & Recovery Center about an accident, injury or workers’ compensation case. Call 1-855-798-2627 (TTY 1-855-797-2627), Monday to Friday, 8 a.m. to 8 p.m. Eastern. The BCRC can also correct Medicare’s record if it is wrong. If you are in a Medicare Advantage plan, call your plan too: it handles coordination and repayment for care it paid for.
- If the other insurer is slow to pay, ask your provider about a conditional payment. Your provider can bill Medicare, and Medicare may make a conditional payment in the meantime. Medicare will expect that money back from any later settlement or award, so keep the letters the BCRC sends you.
- If you are not sure what to do, call 1-800-MEDICARE (1-800-633-4227) or contact your State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP) for free help.
Sources
- CMS: Medicare Secondary Payer Overview — explains when Medicare pays second
- CMS: MSP Manual, Chapter 3 — Liability, No-Fault, and Workers’ Compensation — detailed rules for accident and injury claims
- Medicare.gov: Who Pays First — general coordination of benefits rules
- CMS: Conditional Payment Information — when Medicare pays conditionally, how the BCRC recovers it, and the BCRC phone line
- CMS: Medicare’s Recovery Process — reporting an accident, injury or workers’ compensation case to the BCRC
- CMS: Coordination of Benefits & Recovery Contacts — BCRC hours and TTY number
Check which coverage processed the claim. A Medicare Summary Notice (MSN) is for Original Medicare; a Medicare Advantage plan sends its own coverage decision. A private insurer’s name alone does not identify your coverage: Medigap and standalone drug plans are also private insurance. A Medigap payment dispute follows the supplement insurer’s process, separately from an appeal of Medicare’s claim decision.
Frequently Asked Questions
This information is for educational purposes only and is not legal or medical advice. Always verify with your doctor's office and insurance company.