Medicare Balance Billing: Is This Legal?
Are you getting a bill from a provider for more than what Medicare paid?
"My doctor sent me a bill for the leftover amount"
"The provider wants me to pay the difference"
"I got a balance bill after Medicare paid"
Let's figure out whether this balance bill is legal and what you can do about it.
What This Means
A bill after Medicare pays is not automatically improper. You may owe a deductible or coinsurance. The issue here is excess billing beyond the amount Medicare’s rules allow the provider to collect. Compare the provider’s bill with the patient share on your Medicare Summary Notice (MSN) or plan’s explanation of benefits.
Which coverage paid? The assignment and limiting-charge rules below describe Original Medicare. If you have Medicare Advantage, ask your plan to confirm the covered service and your share of the bill. A disagreement about the plan’s payment or the amount it says you owe can require a plan decision and appeal. QMB protections for Medicare-covered Part A and Part B cost sharing apply in both programs.
Why This Happens
- An allowed patient share looks like an extra charge. A deductible or coinsurance can be valid even after Medicare pays. Check any supplement’s payment too.
- The provider did not accept assignment. Some Original Medicare providers can charge above the approved amount, subject to the applicable limit.
- The provider opted out of Medicare. A valid private contract can make you responsible for the provider’s charges under different rules.
- A billing or eligibility error occurred. The office may have billed an amount it should write off, or failed to recognize your QMB status.
When Balance Billing Is and Is Not Allowed
For Original Medicare, check the provider’s status and whether it accepted assignment for this service:
- Assignment accepted: The provider accepts Medicare’s approved amount as full payment for the covered service. It can collect the applicable deductible and coinsurance, but cannot add an excess charge. Participating providers accept assignment; non-participating providers can also accept it for individual claims.
- Assignment not accepted: For most covered professional services, a non-participating provider can charge up to the applicable limiting charge, generally 115% of the approved amount for a non-participating provider. Some supplies and durable medical equipment are outside that limit. Check the MSN’s Maximum You May Be Billed, if shown, or ask Medicare to confirm the limit for the particular service. Medicare explains assignment and limiting charges.
- QMB status: Providers cannot bill you for Medicare-covered Part A or Part B deductibles, coinsurance or copayments for dates when you have QMB protection. Use the steps below if a bill includes those amounts.
If the provider opted out
With a valid private contract signed before treatment, Medicare’s usual payment limits do not apply, and neither Medicare nor Medigap pays for the privately contracted service (42 CFR 405.415). Ask for a copy of the contract. If you did not sign one, ask Medicare to review the provider’s status and billing; the provider cannot simply treat the bill as unrestricted private payment. The failure-to-maintain-opt-out rules limit what the provider may collect (42 CFR 405.435).
For emergency or urgent care without a prior private contract, an opt-out provider must bill Medicare and may collect no more than the physician limiting charge, or the deductible and coinsurance for a non-physician practitioner. If a valid private contract already existed before the emergency, its terms still apply (42 CFR 405.440).
If You Have QMB and Still Get a Bill
The Qualified Medicare Beneficiary (QMB) program protects you from Medicare-covered Part A and Part B cost sharing. The protection applies even if the provider does not accept Medicaid, your Medicaid is from another state, or Medicaid pays the provider nothing. It applies to Original Medicare and Medicare Advantage providers (CMS QMB billing rules).
- Confirm QMB status for the date of care. Ask Medicare or your state Medicaid office if you are unsure. Having Medicaid or help with Medicare premiums does not by itself establish QMB status.
- Show the billing office proof. Provide your Medicaid or QMB card; with Original Medicare, your MSN can also show QMB status. Ask the office to check the service date and remove prohibited Part A/B cost sharing.
- Ask for correction of any collection referral and a refund of amounts already paid. CMS tells providers to recall improper QMB cost-sharing bills sent to collections and refund collected amounts. Keep copies and ask for written confirmation.
- Escalate if the bills continue. Call 1-800-MEDICARE (1-800-633-4227). If a debt collector continues contacting you about the improper bill, Medicare’s QMB fact sheet explains how to complain to the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau.
This protection concerns Medicare-covered Part A/B cost sharing. A small Medicaid copayment may still apply, and Part D drug costs have separate rules. It does not make every noncovered service free. Medicare’s Savings Programs guide explains the different programs and costs.
Should You Appeal?
If Medicare or your plan processed the covered service correctly but the provider billed more than it may collect, dispute the excess with the billing office and report unresolved improper billing to Medicare.
If you disagree with a coverage or payment decision, follow the appeal instructions on the MSN or plan notice. For Medicare Advantage, ask the plan for a decision about coverage or the amount you must pay. A billing-office inquiry does not extend an appeal deadline.
Medicare distinguishes provider billing questions from coverage and payment appeals. A Medicare Advantage organization determination includes a decision about the amount the plan requires you to pay.
What To Do Next
- Check the bill promptly. Match the service date and item to your MSN or plan statement. Ask billing to explain any difference and confirm the amount still owed after other insurance. If review will take time, request a written hold on the disputed bill and collections; do not assume that asking pauses them.
- For Original Medicare, check assignment and the applicable limit. Ask the billing office whether it accepted assignment for this claim. You can also check participation on Medicare.gov or call Medicare. For Medicare Advantage, ask your plan to confirm your responsibility instead.
- Ask for a corrected bill. Identify the disputed service and amount in writing. If you have QMB, use the proof and escalation steps above. Keep copies of notices, bills, receipts and correspondence.
- Report unresolved improper billing to Medicare. Call 1-800-MEDICARE (1-800-633-4227). Your State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP) can also help you understand the bill and the appropriate dispute route.
- If you already paid too much, request a refund in writing. Include payment records and the notice supporting the correct amount. Report an unresolved refusal to Medicare; your state’s medical board or attorney general’s office may also help with a provider complaint.
Sources
- Medicare.gov: Does Your Provider Accept Medicare as Full Payment? — assignment and limiting charges.
- CMS: Prohibition on Billing Qualified Medicare Beneficiaries — Part A/B protection, service-date eligibility, refunds and collection recalls.
- Medicare.gov: Three Tips for People in the QMB Program — proof of QMB status and escalation.
- Medicare.gov: Medicare Savings Programs — QMB scope and distinct Medicaid/Part D costs.
- Medicare.gov: Filing a Claim — provider billing and payment appeals.
- CMS: Organization Determinations — Medicare Advantage decisions about payment and patient responsibility.
- CMS: No Surprises — Understand Your Rights — Medicare has separate billing protections.
- 42 CFR 405.415: Private Contracts.
- 42 CFR 405.435: Failure to Maintain Opt-Out.
- 42 CFR 405.440: Emergency and Urgent Care.
Frequently Asked Questions
This information is for educational purposes only and is not legal or medical advice. Always verify with your doctor's office and insurance company.